Quote from: bry melvin on June 25, 2010, 12:39:15 PMQuoteNo other passive tone circuit I know of can pull the mid notch like HiWatt.
Curious if that included the on guitar circuit board and tbx (Eric Clapton signature strat)
I build (or have built) all of my strat type guitars with that circuit
I've never used a HiWatt.
Yes I know that's an "active" guitar setup...just curious of the comparison if someone has tried.
I understand the confusion as it's rather hard to get your head around these tone shapes.
In short NO Clap Strat tone circuits are dead. a mere hump of about 5/6 Db from memory. (someone here a while back asked about TBX and I simulated it for them. Sorry no time to search at the mo)
If you feel those onboard tricks bring positives to your sound then by all means use them but bare in mind that it's often only that one guitar an so what you gonna do when you bust a string 2 min before you walk on stage and you are forced to use a bog standard Axe.
I always look at it from a live gig situation/ on the road so to speak.
When you are famous you can have anything you want,,, heck they will come to you then.
Meanwhile having built all the famour tone circuits (In Amps) there is Absolutly none that can do a true *Notch Mid Cut*
Side note:
Jack1962 ,, observation is (I assume) talking about the AMP As A WHOLE.
Whereas I'm refering to *Tone Stacks* as a *Seperate Entitey*
Entirely observed on there own merit.
It would be an eye opener if Jack inserted the HiWatt Tone into the Dumble,,
He would be in for a big suprise.
That said if smudgy tone is your thing then I have no arguement.
For me the *notching effect* is far less lossy that big sloping curves.
Heres how it works:
LOOK carefully at the pic,
If you make any CUT in freq broard and shallow then you also pull out a lot of energy in the signal path. (some could argue that with the power of a Dumble POWER matters little,,, yeah right and like EVERYONE OWNS an Dumble???)
Meanwhile back in the real world.
Where was I?
By implimenting a steep notch when cutting the mid you achieve better results as you suck less energy from your signal. You are wasting less energy this way.
I can't find the snap I wanted of a HiWatt / Dumble shootout so this will have to do tonight. It will give you some *Visual idea* of what is happening.
Notice the *Tonemender has a soft dished effect on the sound*.
This is the classic Fender mid scooped effect.
Now look at my Modded HiWatt tone !!!! Trust me this is stunning in front of a simple fuzz box like a TS9.
And I'm sorry to say that the Clapton or TBX tone circuits can only dream about these tone shapes.
Hope it helps,,Phil